Sources -- Sean Payton struggled with choosing Taysom Hill over Jameis Winston as New Orleans Saints' starting QB

 espn.com  11/22/2020 14:20:18 
play
Payton explains decision to name Taysom Hill starting QB (1:16)

Saints head coach Sean Payton tells Dianna Russini why the team decided to start Taysom Hill at quarterback instead of Jameis Winston. (1:16)

6:44 AM ET

New Orleans coach Sean Payton struggled with choosing the Saints' starting quarterback for Sunday's game before ultimately deciding to go with Taysom Hill, but multiple players and people within the organization thought Jameis Winston should have been the starter against the Atlanta Falcons, sources told ESPN.

Payton knew that whichever quarterback he decided on -- Hill or Winston -- would lead to a specific and different type of game plan. The longtime coach went with the quarterback whom the Saints assured last spring -- as he was signing his two-year extension -- that he would get a chance to start if Drew Brees ever got hurt.

The Saints view this as a chance to get an evaluation of Hill at quarterback now and for the future, with Brees still likely to retire after this season, according to sources.

Going with Hill on Sunday does not preclude Winston from taking over for Brees as the Saints' quarterback of the future. Winston has impressed Saints coaches and players and remains a potential part of New Orleans' long-term plans.

There continues to be a widespread expectation that this will be Brees' final season, according to sources around the league. Hill's two-year, $21 million contract pays him as if he will be the starting quarterback next season, and Winston is on a one-year deal.

Many people close to the situation are operating as if the 2020 season will be Brees' last, although the Saints also thought 2019 would be the future Hall of Famer's final season. After the Pro Bowl ended last January, Brees and the Saints' coaches shared an emotional moment, thinking that was the end before Brees decided to return for the 2020 season.

There is no concrete timetable on how long Brees will be sidelined while recovering from fractured ribs and a collapsed lung, but the phrase "four to five weeks" came up a few times last week from various sources. Brees was placed on injured reserve Friday, meaning he will miss at least three games -- beginning with Sunday's contest against Atlanta.

Brees told ESPN's Ed Werder on Sunday that doctors have been encouraged by his progress, specifically improvement in lung function and the continued dissipation of the pneumothorax suffered in the first half of last Sunday's victory over the San Francisco 49ers. The 13-time Pro Bowler told Werder he is hopeful that he will be ready to play as soon as he is eligible in Week 14.

Payton told ESPN's Dianna Russini on Sunday morning that Hill "has had a real good week of preparation. He deserves this opportunity."

"And we've had a chance to see him play that position a lot more than anyone else. When the fans have seen him, he's been in a different role," stressed Payton, who also added that the decision was based on, "This week, how do we win this game?"

Payton said Winston did "a great job last week" after Brees left the game with his injuries at halftime. But he said the team understood going into this season that if Brees ever got hurt during the middle of the game, "we weren't gonna be able to make a switch to Taysom with the roles he's playing in the kicking game on offense."

"But with a full week of preparation, we're excited for him today," Payton said. "It'll be exciting. It'll be different. He's a different type of quarterback, and that had a lot to do with us holding off any announcement. Because they're two entirely different quarterbacks when you look at Jameis and when you look at Taysom. And I'm glad we've got both of 'em -- we're gonna need both of 'em this year."

« Go back