George Pell's lawyer apologises for 'plain vanilla' comment as new details emerge

 sbs.com.au  02/28/2019 06:06:02 

Further details of George Pell's investigation have been released by Victorian courts as the cardinal faces his second night behind bars.

Updated
Presented by Maani Truu, Nick Baker

Cardinal George Pell's barrister has apologised for describing the acts of Pell's sexual assault of two 13-year-old choirboys as "plain, vanilla sexual penetration" in court.

Robert Richter QC's remarks, uttered during a plea hearing for Pell who is currently behind bars awaiting sentencing, garnered significant outrage online.

"After spending a sleepless night reflecting upon the terrible choice of a phrase I used in court during the course of a long and stressful process, I offer my sincerest apologies to all who were hurt or offended by it," he said in a statement released on Thursday.

Robert Richter QC leaves the County Court in Melbourne on Wednesday.
Robert Richter QC leaves the County Court in Melbourne on Wednesday.

"I apologise profusely to all who interpreted it in a way it was never intended: it was in no way meant to belittle or minimise the suffering and hurt of victims of sex abuse, and in retrospect, I can see why it caused great offence to many."

Earlier on Thursday, video showing the moment Pell was confronted with the allegations that he sexually abused two choirboys was revealed publically for the first time. 

The footage, released by Victoria's County Court, shows Pell reading from a pre-prepared statement, that he had compiled knowing the nature of the allegations against him.

"From what I've been told the allegations involve vile and disgusting conduct contrary to everything I hold dear," he said.

George Pell in Rome when he was first interviewed in relation to allegations he sexually abused two choirboys.
George Pell in Rome when he was first interviewed in relation to allegations he sexually abused two choirboys.

"What a load of absolute and disgraceful rubbish, completely false, madness."

The interview took place in Rome in 2016, after Australian police questioned the cardinal inside the Hilton Hotel, not far from the Vatican. He was formally charged almost eight months later. 

The footage was released alongside photos showing where Pell committed the abuse. 

The photos, which were used as evidence in Pell's trial, are of the hallway and priest's sacristy at Melbourne's St Patrick's Cathedral.

The two boys "nicked off" after a Sunday solemn mass in late 1996 and were caught swigging sacramental wine in the priest's sacristy by Pell, who had been newly installed as Archbishop of Melbourne.

The sacristy at St Patrick's Cathedral.
The sacristy at St Patrick's Cathedral.

Pell scolded them, exposed his penis from beneath the ornate ceremonial robes, and molested them.

A Melbourne jury in December found Pell guilty of five charges - one of sexually penetrating a child and four of committing indecent acts with children.

The hallway leading to the sacristy.
The hallway leading to the sacristy.

It comes as Victoria Police confirmed it was not investigating any other cases involving Australia's highest ranked Catholic.

"No, not involving George Pell. No I don't believe we are doing any other investigations there," Chief Commissioner Graham Ashton told 3AW radio.

"Over and above what has been handled, not that I am aware of."

The sacristy at St Patrick's Cathedral.
The sacristy at St Patrick's Cathedral.

The 77-year-old served will now serve his second night in jail after being remanded in custody on Wednesday.

Pell won't apply for bail or pursue his appeal until after he is sentenced by County Court chief judge Peter Kidd on March 13.

During Wednesday's plea hearing, Mr Richter conceded jail is inevitable, while senior crown prosecutor Mark Gibson SC signalled the jail time will likely be "significant".

Each of the five charges Pell was convicted on by a jury last December carries a 10-year maximum sentence.

"For high-profile prisoners, certainly they have to take all appropriate measures to keep them safe and I am sure they will be doing that in this case," Chief Commissioner Ashton told 3AW on Thursday.

Cardinal George Pell remains in high esteem by many powerful bishops.
Cardinal George Pell remains in high esteem by many powerful bishops.

Former prime minister John Howard was among 10 people to submit a character reference to the court and described Pell, who he had known about 30 years, as of "high intelligence and exemplary character".

"I am aware he has been convicted of those charges; that an appeal against the conviction has been lodged and that he maintains his innocence in respect of these charges. None of these matters alter my opinion of the Cardinal," Mr Howard said in his statement.

"Strength and sincerity have always been features of his personality.

"I have always found him to be lacking hypocrisy and cant. In his chosen vocation he has frequently displayed much courage and held to his values and beliefs, irrespective of the prevailing wisdom of the time.

"It is my view that he has dedicated his life to his nation and his church."

Cardinal George Pell in Rome. The church has been urged to act on the disgraced cleric as soon as possible.
Cardinal George Pell in Rome. The church has been urged to act on the disgraced cleric as soon as possible.

Judge Kidd regards Pell as unlikely to reoffend, while prosecutors say he is remorseless and shows no insight into his crimes.

Pell will be registered as a serious sex offender.

Those seeking information or support relating to child sexual assault can contact Bravehearts on 1800 272 831 or Blue Knot on 1300 657 380. Lifeline is available 24 hours a day on 13 11 14. With AAP

Stay up to date with SBS NEWS

  • App
  • Subscribe
  • Follow
  • Listen
  • Watch

SBS News App

Download our free app on the App Store or Google Play for the latest headlines and breaking news alerts.

SBS News on social

Follow SBS News to join in the conversation and never miss the latest live updates.

Latest News podcasts

Ask Amazon Alexa for the latest SBS News or listen to SBS Radio.

Daily Bulletin

Watch SBS World News live daily at 6:30pm on TV and on our app. Catch up on SBS On Demand.

« Go back