President Donald Trump on December 4 dismissed the significance of repeated contacts between his personal attorney Rudy Giuliani and phone numbers linked to the White House and its budget office - contacts that were first revealed in a House Intelligence Committee impeachment report released earlier this week.
So somebody said he made a phone call into the White House. What difference does that make? Mr. Trump said to reporters during a meeting with Italys Prime Minister on the sidelines of a NATO meeting outside of London.
Is that supposed to be a big deal? he added. I dont think so.
The 300-page report laying out the case against Mr. Trump is serving as the basis for the next phase of the impeachment inquiry House Judiciary Committee hearings that are expected to precede the drafting of formal articles of impeachment against him. On December 4, the committee heard from law professors who discussed the constitutional origins of Congress impeachment power and debated whether Mr. Trump committed an impeachable offense when he asked the president of Ukraine to investigate a Democratic political rival and potentially held up critical security aid to pressure him.
The report, which was made public on December 3, includes a summary of phone records obtained by the committee showing extensive contact between Mr. Giuliani and the White House, as well as a caller identified only as -1.
On April 24, for instance, Mr. Giuliani spoke three times with a number linked to the Office of Management and Budget (OMB) the office that delayed the release of hundreds of millions in earmarked Ukrainian aid money and he spoke eight times with a number linked to the White House, the documents show.
Later that night, the State Department phoned then-Ambassador to Ukraine Marie Yovanovitch and abruptly called her home from Kyiv because of concerns from up the street at the White House.
The release of the phone logs in the report sparked search efforts at the White House and in the budget office to try to track down who had been in touch with Mr. Giuliani, to no apparent avail.
OMB officials told that a staff review showed that nobody there has ever spoken to Mr. Giuliani. White House acting chief of staff Mick Mulvaney still uses the cellphone he had when he ran the budget office, leading some to suspect that he may be the holder of the OMB Phone Number. But a senior White House official said a review of his cellphone records did not turn up any calls between Mr. Mulvaney and Mr. Giuliani on the days cited in the report. The official spoke on condition of anonymity to discuss internal records.
Meanwhile, Mr. Trump on Wednesday insisted he knew nothing about the calls, even as he maintained they were no big deal. He also defended Mr. Giuliani as a very good lawyer, a great crime fighter and the best mayor in the history of New York City.
Rudy is a great gentleman and theyre after him only because hes done such a good job. He was very effective against Mueller and the Mueller hoax, Mr. Trump said, referring to former special counsel Robert Muellers investigation into Russian meddling in the 2016 election.
Mr. Giuliani, too, weighed in by tweet.
The mere fact I had numerous calls with the White House does not establish any specific topic, he wrote, adding, Remember, Im the Presidents attorney. The White House has a full legal office that handles official matters.
Mr. Giuliani has long pushed the debunked conspiracy theory that Ukraine interfered in the 2016 election and is accused of trying to pressure Ukrainian officials to investigate the son of Mr. Trumps potential Democratic challenger Joe Biden. Hunter Biden was on the board of a Ukrainian energy company, Burisma, when his father worked at the White House.
The phone records released on December 3 also raised new questions about the role of California Rep. Devin Nunes, the top Republican on the House Intelligence Committee. Mr. Nunes, the records show, had a series of calls with Mr. Giuliani, as well as with Mr. Giulianis now-indicted associate Lev Parnas. One conversation with Mr. Parnas on April 12 lasted eight minutes, according to call logs.
Mr. Nunes told Fox News host Sean Hannity that its possible he talked to Mr. Parnas, but claimed he wasnt sure because he hadnt gone through all his phone records.
I dont really recall that name. I remember the name now because he has been indicted, Mr. Nunes said, adding that any conversation with Mr. Parnas would have been appropriate.
Asked if Mr. Nunes should have told House Intelligence Chairman Adam Schiff about his conversations with people under investigation, McCarthy instead criticised Mr. Schiff for his offices communication with the whistle blower whose complaint sparked the impeachment inquiry.