During a panel discussion in New Delhi in mid-January, Gen. Bipin Rawat, India's Chief of Defense Staff, said children were being radicalized by extremist militants in Kashmir and there was a need to separate them.
"Girls and boys as young as 10 and 12 are now being radicalized. These people can still be isolated from radicalization in a gradual way, but there are people who have completely been radicalized," Rawat said at the Raisina Dialogue, an international conference on geopolitics attended by global leaders in politics, diplomacy and business.
"These people need to be taken out separately, possibly taken into some deradicalization camps."
Rawat also appeared to indicate that such camps already existed. "We have deradicalisation camps going on in our country," said Rawat, though he did not provide any additional details on the nature of the camps, or where they might be located.
"I am quite baffled by the statement. Has anyone actually identified where these camps are, what they are?" said Manoj Joshi, fellow at the Observer Research Foundation, an Indian think tank.
"Is it possible to keep something like that quiet in the country? If there are camps, then it is very serious. What is the process on how people are sent to them?"
It is unclear exactly what Rawat, who has been known to make outlandish statements, meant by his remarks, or whether there is a plan or policy in place to establish camps. Indian government and military officials have declined to comment on the general's remarks. The Indian Defense Ministry and the Home Ministry declined to comment.
Rawat, a four-star general who was head of the India Army, now holds another extremely influential position as Chief of Defense Staff, which means he is the principle adviser to the Defense Minister.
Dilbag Singh, the top police official in Jammu and Kashmir did not back Rawat's claim that camps existed.
Instead he said that the formation of such camps would be a welcome addition to the valley. "If any such facility comes up in Kashmir, it will be a good sign. It will definitely help people," said Singh at a press conference earlier this week.
Some commentators have said there is no evidence of such camps in India.
"I don't recall anything (about deradicalization camps)," said Harsh Pant, professor of international relations at King's College, London, and an expert on Indian defense strategy and policy.
"It seems that this was an off-the-cuff remark. I think he did not understand the importance of the comment. India needs a deradicalization strategy and has been unable to come up with it. There has always been that problem on how you deal with radicalized individuals."
"Where advice and education can be imparted to parents and their wards who have probably been led astray ... There appears no information in the public domain about any such 'deradicalization camps' mentioned," he said.
"The hangover of the CAA and NRC agitation which revealed information about detention centers for 'aliens', something denied by the Indian government, has obviously had a psychological effect too; hence, the high level of sensitivity at the mention of 'deradicalization camps'," wrote Hasnain.
In Kashmir, Rawat's comments about potentially separating children into camps are even more controversial.
Travel curfews and roadblocks were established, and millions of residents in India's only Muslim-majority state were cut off from their families in other parts of the country. Officials in Kashmir told of mass detentions, while residents said tear gas and pellet guns were used against Kashmiri citizens.
Talk of camps -- however tenuous the claim -- could risk more unrest in the volatile region and
who believe Indian security forces already wield a heavy hand in Kashmir.
Pakistan, which claims Kashmir in its entirety, said it condemns the "highly irresponsible remarks."
A violent separatist movement is ongoing in Kashmir and a number of terrorist and militant groups are active there. But the estimate on the number of militants currently in the region is small -- about 300 people joined militant groups between 2010-2016, according the Ministry of Home Affairs.
However in recent years there has been a rise in the number of minors who have joined such groups, according to Joshi, from the Observer Research Foundation.
But in his comments, Gen. Rawat didn't appear to distinguish between young Kashmiris who had joined militant groups and those protesting as citizens.
"There are young people who have been radicalized who are pelting stones," Rawat said. "You see how a terrorist operates," he added, appearing to suggest that young people were protesting because they'd been radicalized, rather than being angry about recent infringements on their freedom.
For many, opposition to the Indian government's actions in Kashmir is political, not religious.
India has put some deradicalization programs in place, particularly when governments were trying to stifle the growth of ISIS, but the country "does not have a dedicated deradicalization policy," said Pant, the expert from King's College.
While some say there is a need for smarter efforts to stop religious extremism from spreading, especially among young people, sequestering people in camps is a dangerous move.
"If you take the kind of steps the Chinese have taken, it will end up backfiring. There is a population that is radicalized but there is a larger population which wants effective governance," Pant said.
"It is not possible -- operationally and logically."