Best smart speakers: Which deliver the best combination of digital assistant and audio performance?

 techhive.com  10/18/2019 10:00:00  8  Michael Brown

You neednt live in a smart home to benefit from a smart speaker. Alexa, Google Assistant, Siri, Cortana, and other digital assistants can help you in dozens of ways, and you dont have to lift a finger to summon themjust speak their names. If you already know you want a smart speaker, scroll down for our top recommendations.

But consider your decision carefully. In a perfect world, these devices would be interoperable, so you could buy one brand because its better for music, another brand because its the best for smart home control, and a third because its superior for retrieving general information from the internet. Thats not how it works in the real world. Once you commit to one platform, youll want to stick with it.

On the upside, choosing one brand of smart speaker over another generally wont tie you into that brands entire ecosystem. Buying an Amazon Echo, for instance, wont limit you to subscribing to Amazons music servicesyou can also use it with Spotify, Pandora, SiriusXM radio, and several other services.And even if you have a smart home system from one company, you can control smart home products that would be otherwise incompatible with that system with voice commandsprovided theyre compatible with your digital assistant of choice.

Updated October 18, 2019to add our take on the all new Google Nest Mini. Google did a lot more than re-brand its smallest smart speaker. The company has improvved its sounds and added a bunch of new features, all while keeping the price tag the same. That said, the Nest Mini is still our runner-up pick in the entry-level category.

sonos beam with samsung q7f smart tv Michael Brown / IDG

An increasing number of soundbars double as smart speakers. The Sonos Beam is powered by Amazons Alexa now, but the company promises to add Google Assistant support before the end of 2018.

That said, if youre wedded to Google Play Music, streaming music from your account to an Amazon Echo is not perfectly seamless (the same goes for streaming music from Amazons services to a Google Home). And there are some major coexistence exceptions: Google is currently blocking its YouTube videos from appearing on the Echo Show and Echo Spot devices, for instance (although you can get there using a web browser on the second-generation Echo Show), and Apples HomePod will stream music only from Apple Music. If you plan to mix and match third-party products with your smart speaker, do the research to make sure theyll work together.

If you want to know more about what smart speakers can do in general before you pick one, skip down to the What can smart speakers do? section.

Best all-around smart speaker

The best smart speakers have displays to convey visual information: Everything from song lyrics, to weather forecasts, shopping lists, videos, security camera feeds, and more. Amazons latest smart speaker, the Echo Show 5, strikes the perfect balance between screen size and price, with a 5.5-inch display and a price tag of just $90. If thats still too high for your budget, the displayless Echo Dot (3rd Gen) costs just $50, but it frequently goes on sale for much less.

Runner-up

Google got off to an uncharacteristically slow start in this spaceand it recently muddied the waters by rejiggering the Nest brands role in its smart home strategybut the Google Nest Hubis definitely giving Amazon a run for its money. The Google Assistant isfar better when it comes to asking for general information, and Google has aggressively added support for third-party smart home products and services.This is also the best choice for folks who are deep into the Chromecast ecosystem, Google Photos, YouTube, andYouTube Music.

Best entry-level smart speaker

If you use a smart speaker mostly to control your smart home devices, and you dont care as much about audio performance, pick up a second-generation Echo Dot while you can. Amazon is selling them for just $39 (thats $10 less than the third-gen model). If you want a better-sounding smart speaker on a budget, on the other hand, you cant go wrong with the third-generation Echo Dot. Amazon significantly improved this speakers audio performance, so its now the best-sounding smart speaker for the money. You can pair two of them for stereo, and you can add an Echo Sub to enhance low-end frequency response.

Runner-up

Google once again takes the runner-up spot here, despite the improvements the company has made to its rebranded smart speaker. Yes, audio quality has improved, and Google Assistant is still smarter than Alexa, but Amazon is ahead of the game when it comes to hooks into the smart home, and if you care about audio, you can supplement the Echo Dot with a bona fide subwoofer. If youre deep into the Google and Neste ecosystems, on the other hand, the Nest Mini will serve you well.

Best smart speaker for music

Its no contest on this score, Google Home Max is the best-sounding smart speaker weve heard, although Apples HomePod comes close. Four Class D amplifiers drive two 4.5-inch aluminum cone, high-excursion woofers with dual voice coils. Two more amps are dedicated to a pair of 0.7-inch polyester dome tweeters. The amps have integrated DACs capable of supporting up to 24-bit/192kHz bit streams, although Google says its only tested sampling rates up to 48kHz. This speaker will fill even larger rooms with sound, but if you find that one just isnt enough, you can pair two for stereo.

Runner-up

If the Google Home Max is beyond your budget, give the Sonos One a listen. Its currently compatible only with Amazons Alexa, but the company promises to add Google Assistant capabilities this spring. Its about the same size as the older Sonos Play:1, but it sounds even better. Despite the similarity in appearance, Sonos designed its smart speaker from scratch. Sonos is the king of multi-room audio, and no other brand supports more music services. Whats more, once you have a Sonos One on your network, you can control all your other Sonos speakers with voice commands, tooand from any Alexa-compatible speaker. The newer Sonos Beam offers the same voice-control features in a smallish soundbar form factor.

Best smart speaker with a large display

Amazon regains the top spot in this category with its all-new Amazon Echo Show (2nd Gen). The new speaker has a bigger, higher-resolution display, much improved audio performance, and Amazon has significantly improved the touchscreen-based user interface (especially when youre browsing Amazons own entertainment offerings). Amazon also added a Zigbee-based smart home hub that allows you to control things like Philips Hue smart bulbs without need of the Hue Bridge.

The Echo Show retains all the great features we loved in the first generation, including the ability to make video calls to people on your contact list (it can also function as a video intercom within your home). And Amazon has made important improvements to its Alexa digital assistant. You can add multiple items to your shopping list, for example, without having to repeat the Alexa wake word: Say Alexa, add cheese, vegetables, coffee, and ice cream to my shopping list, for instance, and each of those grocery items will appear as discrete items on your list that you can remove with a swipe of your finger when you buy them.

Runner-up

The Google Home Hubs $149 price tag makes up for lot of missing features, and were sure Google will sell a bazillion of these smart displays over time. Google Assistant is a powerful competitor to Amazons Alexa, Apples Siri, and Microsofts Cortana, but in spite of its name, the Google Home Hub isnt a true smart home hubunless all of your smart devices communicate via Wi-Fi or Bluetooth. Weve criticized the second-generation Echo Show for not including a Z-Wave radio, but Googles smart display doesnt even have a Zigbee radio onboard.

Google is reportedly working to remedy the limitation that prevents you from grouping multiple Chromecast video devices, so that smart displays like this one, as well as the Lenovo Smart Display and the JBL Link View, can be used for multi-room audio, but the Google Home Hub will never get a camera so it cant match the Echo Shows ability to perform video calls and serve as an in-home video intercom. But we cant say it enough: that $149 price tag renders almost all of the Google Home Hubs shortcomings pretty meaningless.

What can smart speakers do?

With the exception of Amazons Echo, smart speakers are powered by the same digital assistants used with smartphones. Siri comes from the iPhone, Google Assistant comes from Android phones, and Cortana from Microsofts now-dead Windows Phone platform (Cortana has since found a home in Windows 10). Alexa was created exclusively for the Amazon Echo, but can now be found in a host of other devices, ranging from the Ecobee4 smart thermostat to the Logitech ZeroTouch phone dock.

At its most basic, a digital assistant is cloud-based software that understands natural language voice commands, performing tasks and fetching information for you. In the real world, digital assistants arent quite as sophisticated as that. While you dont need to talk like a robote.g., Alexa, set timer, 20 minutesthey do get confused easily, and youll hear a fair amount of responses such as Sorry, I dont know that one (thats an Alexa phrase, incidentally) when you trip them up. The cool thing is that the algorithms powering digital assistants can learn over time and become better at predicting what you need.

Here are just a few of the things that most smart speakers can do (you can add and more! to the end of each bullet list):

Entertain

  • Stream music over Wi-Fi
  • Stream music over Bluetooth (most models)
  • Work with Chromecast devices (Google Home models)
  • Control your TV
  • Stream music to multiple speakers (multi-room audio)
  • Play games
  • Stream videos (models with displays)

Retrieve news and information

  • News headlines
  • Weather forecasts
  • Traffic reports
  • Date and time
  • Wikipedia entries

Manage your schedule

  • Set appointments
  • Provide reminders
  • Serve as an alarm clock
  • Maintain to-do lists

Help in the kitchen

  • Recite recipes (and show them on models with displays)
  • Set multiple timers
  • Get measurement conversions (How many cups are in one quart?)
  • Maintain shopping lists
  • Set the temperature for a sous vide cooker
  • Get nutrition information (How many calories are in an apple?)

Contact friends and family

  • Make and receive phone calls (video calls on models with displays)
  • Serve as an in-home intercom
  • Send text messages

Control your smart home *

* There are caveats when it comes to using a smart speaker for home control. Smart home devices that can be controlled via Wi-Fi dont require any other hardware. Products that use the Zigbee or Z-Wave protocols depend on the presence of a smart-home hub, such as a Samsung SmartThings or Wink Hub. Amazons Echo Plusand its second-generation Echo Show are exceptions to that rule, because they have an integrated smart home controller (although its limited to Zigbee)

Our latest smart speaker reviews

Well update this list as new models arrive.

« Go back