Chintan Girish Modi reviews Bans and Bar Girls: Performing Caste in Mumbais Dance Bars, by Sameena Dalwai

 thehindu.com  05/22/2020 09:23:16 

Sameena Dalwai is an assistant professor at the Jindal Global Law School, specialising in legal issues connected to the domain of gender and sexuality. Her book, Bans and Bar Girls: Performing Caste in Mumbais Dance Bars, draws on several years of experience as a lawyer with human rights organisations in Maharashtra and her doctoral dissertation focusing on a legal ban meant to curtail the rising visibility and power of bar dancers. It holds great value for readers interested in economic liberalisation, labour rights, feminist politics and the Dalit movement.

Globalisation in the late 1980s and 1990s facilitated a new market of entertainment as a result of which a dance bar industry emerged in Mumbai, writes Dalwai, who uses Stanley Cohens theory of moral panic to analyse how public opinion was mobilised against women from traditional performing communities perceived as earning far more money than they ought to. The ban did not shut down bars. It only prohibited bar girls from dancing to the same Bollywood songs that are considered respectable when they are played at upper caste weddings.

Caste capital

Dalwai uses the concept of caste capital to talk about how women from certain castes were able to use hereditary skills of dancing, drama and seduction to acquire money, status and power through their occupation. The ban took away their right to choice of work, reduced their income, and affected their expenditure on food, education and healthcare. Cohens theory is well-chosen to help contextualise how dance bars emerged with economic liberalisation, a time with major societal changes that threatened older structures defined by caste and class hierarchies. The function of moral panic at this moment was to try and restore a sense of order through the enforcement of norms and punitive action to contain deviance. While it was alleged that dance bars were breeding grounds for criminal activity, debates around law and order were articulated through the language of morality not illegality. This distinction made by Dalwai is subtle but powerfully expressed.

Threat to society

In Mumbai, moral panic at the existence and popularity of dance bars was catalysed by influential state and political actors. Those controlling the discourse around dance bars were retired judges, politicians and activists, writes Dalwai. These people were able to craft a narrative depicting dance bars and bar girls as a threat to society in general, and Maharashtrian culture in particular. They were able to influence the media, and put pressure on the legislature, to make them believe that the bar girls needed to be out of business because they lured supposedly impressionable young men, and wrecked their families.

Dalwais research is an example of rigorous scholarship. Her fieldwork took place in Mumbai from June 2008 to February 2009. She conducted interviews with various parties linked directly to the ban, thus enriching the readers understanding of the issue at hand. She spoke to bar girls, bar owners, and bar staff, politicians, activists, lawyers, police officers, and men who frequented dance bars. Her research also included looking at clippings from Marathi and English newspapers, parliamentary debates, petitions to and judgments by the courts, and the differences of opinion between Dalit and upper caste feminist collectives.

Dalwai interprets the moral panic as a manifestation of Brahminical patriarchy, and its hegemonic ideas of womens chastity and sexuality, which pits the good wife against the bad other woman. Upper caste men are conveniently excused from taking any responsibility in a social universe that grants them numerous privileges on account of their gender and caste location. What is more interesting is that the Maharashtra government encouraged the dance bar market from its inception, regulated it, and earned taxes from it but actively supported the call for a ban when questions about morality began to be raised. Politicians never fail to surprise.

Bans and Bar Girls: Performing Caste in Mumbais Dance Bars; Sameena Dalwai, Women Unlimited, 595.

The reviewer is a freelance writer.

Dear reader,

We have been keeping you up-to-date with information on the developments in India and the world that have a bearing on our health and wellbeing, our lives and livelihoods, during these difficult times. To enable wide dissemination of news that is in public interest, we have increased the number of articles that can be read free, and extended free trial periods. However, we have a request for those who can afford to subscribe: please do. As we fight disinformation and misinformation, and keep apace with the happenings, we need to commit greater resources to news gathering operations. We promise to deliver quality journalism that stays away from vested interest and political propaganda.

Support Quality Journalism
« Go back